Anatomy of a civil case

Ten stages. Four court systems.

Every civil lawsuit follows roughly the same path. The names, clocks and paperwork change with the court. Pick a court system and the page re-reads itself for it.

Federal district court (S.D.N.Y. as the reference)

  1. 01

    Filing and case number

    A plaintiff files a complaint and pays a fee. The clerk opens a case, assigns a number and, sooner or later, a judge. Nothing binds the defendant yet.

    Number looks like1:25-cv-01234

    The complaint is filed through ECF with a civil cover sheet. The case is assigned at random to a district judge, and often a magistrate judge too, and the number carries the division, year and case type.

    On the docketEntries for the complaint, the civil cover sheet, the issued summons and the judge assignment appear within a day or two.

    TermsComplaintECF No.Case numberPACER

  2. 02

    Service

    The defendant has to be formally told. Until service is complete, the defendant’s response clock has not started, which is why a case can look quiet for months.

    Time to serve90 days

    Rule 4(m) gives 90 days from filing to serve the summons and complaint. A defendant can agree to waive formal service, which gives that defendant 60 days to respond instead of 21.

    On the docketAn executed summons or a waiver of service, usually with a sworn proof of service.

    TermsService of processAffidavit of serviceSummons

  3. 03

    The defendant responds

    The defendant must answer or ask the court to dismiss. A defendant who does neither can be defaulted, though courts often undo defaults.

    Time to respond21 days

    Rule 12(a) gives 21 days after service, or 60 if service was waived. Lawyers usually extend the deadline by stipulation or a letter motion, so the real date is often set by an order.

    On the docketA stipulation or letter extending time, then either an answer or a motion to dismiss.

    TermsAnswerDefaultLetter motionStipulation and order

  4. 04

    Challenging the complaint

    Before any evidence, a defendant can argue that even if everything alleged is true, the law gives no remedy, or that the court lacks power. The judge accepts the allegations for this purpose only. It is not a finding that they are true.

    The motionRule 12(b)

    A motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, lack of jurisdiction or similar grounds. Many judges require a short pre-motion letter first, and may hold a conference before allowing briefing. A dismissal is often with leave to amend.

    On the docketA pre-motion letter and response, then the motion, memorandum of law, declarations, opposition and reply.

    TermsMotion to dismissFailure to state a claimPre-motion letterIndividual practicesWith prejudice and without prejudice

  5. 05

    Early conferences and the schedule

    Once the complaint survives, the judge sets deadlines for discovery, motions and trial, usually after a conference with the lawyers.

    First meetingRule 16 conference

    The parties submit a discovery plan and the judge issues a scheduling order. A magistrate judge may be assigned to manage discovery and settlement talks.

    On the docketA scheduling order, a notice of an initial conference, and often a referral to the magistrate judge.

    TermsScheduling orderMagistrate judgeMeet and confer

  6. 06

    Discovery

    Each side gets evidence from the other and from outsiders: documents, written questions, sworn testimony. Most disputes here are settled by the lawyers, and a judge steps in only when asked.

    Written questions25 per party

    Initial disclosures, interrogatories (25, counting subparts), document requests, admissions and depositions (one day of seven hours each, ten per side). In the Southern District of New York a dispute starts with a letter to the judge under Local Civil Rule 37.2.

    On the docketMostly quiet. Letters, protective orders and motions to compel are what surface.

    TermsDiscoveryInterrogatoriesRequest for productionDepositionRequest for admissionProtective orderMotion to compel

  7. 07

    Summary judgment

    After discovery, either side can ask the judge to decide some or all claims without a trial because the facts that matter are not in genuine dispute. Unlike a motion to dismiss, this one rests on evidence.

    The standardNo genuine dispute of material fact

    Rule 56. In the Southern District of New York the movant also files a numbered statement of undisputed facts (Local Civil Rule 56.1), and the other side responds point by point. A judge can grant it on part of the case.

    On the docketA motion, Rule 56.1 statements, memoranda, declarations and a pile of exhibits.

    TermsMotion for summary judgmentDeclarationExhibit

  8. 08

    Trial

    If the case is not resolved, it goes to a judge or jury. Before trial the court sorts out what evidence will be allowed. Many cases settle in the last weeks.

    Jury verdictUnanimous

    A civil jury has between six and twelve people and must be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise (Rule 48). A joint pretrial order and motions in limine come first.

    On the docketA joint pretrial order, motions in limine, proposed jury instructions and a verdict form.

    TermsBench trial and jury trialFinal pretrial orderMotion in limineJury instructionsVerdict

  9. 09

    Judgment and post-trial motions

    A verdict becomes a judgment only when the court enters it. The loser can ask the same judge to change the result before appealing. The clock for an appeal usually runs from the entry or notice of entry.

    Post-trial motions28 days

    The judgment is entered as a separate document (Rule 58). Motions for judgment as a matter of law or a new trial are due within 28 days of entry. Costs and fees are asked for by later motion.

    On the docketA judgment, then post-trial motions, then a bill of costs.

    TermsJudgmentJudgment as a matter of lawAttorney’s fees

  10. 10

    Appeal

    The loser asks a higher court to review the ruling for legal error. The appeals court usually works from the written record and briefs, and does not hear new evidence.

    Time to appeal30 days

    A notice of appeal is due 30 days after the judgment is entered (60 if the United States is a party). The Second Circuit hears Manhattan appeals, deciding many by non-precedential summary order. Appeals before a final judgment are rare.

    On the docketA notice of appeal on the trial docket, then a new appellate case with its own number.

    TermsNotice of appealCircuit court of appealsSummary orderInterlocutory appealMandate

Ways out before the end

Any stage can be the last. Most civil cases never reach trial.

  • SettlementThe parties agree, often confidentially. The docket shows only a notice of settlement and a dismissal.
  • Voluntary dismissalThe plaintiff ends the case, by notice, stipulation or court order. New York calls it discontinuance.
  • Default judgmentA defendant who never responds can lose without a hearing, though defaults are often set aside.
  • DismissalThe court ends a claim. Whether the plaintiff may file again depends on whether it is with or without prejudice.
  • Withdrawal of counselA lawyer leaving does not end a case. A stay often gives the client time to find another lawyer or proceed pro se.
Compare all four side by side
StageFederalNew YorkCaliforniaFlorida
Filing and case number Number looks like1:25-cv-01234 Number looks like150123/2025 Number looks like25SMCV01234 Number looks like2025-012345-CA-01
Service Time to serve90 days Time to serve120 days Proof of service60 days Time to serve120 days
The defendant responds Time to respond21 days Time to respond20 or 30 days Time to respond30 days Time to respond20 days
Challenging the complaint The motionRule 12(b) The motionCPLR 3211 The motionDemurrer The motionMotion to dismiss
Early conferences and the schedule First meetingRule 16 conference First meetingPreliminary conference First meetingCase management conference First meetingCase management order
Discovery Written questions25 per party Written questionsLimited by case type Written questions35 special Written questions30 including subparts
Summary judgment The standardNo genuine dispute of material fact The standardNo triable issue of fact The standardNo triable issue of material fact The standardFederal standard since 2021
Trial Jury verdictUnanimous Jury verdict5 of 6 jurors Jury verdict9 of 12 jurors Jury sizeGenerally 6
Judgment and post-trial motions Post-trial motions28 days EntryCounty clerk enters it Post-trial motions15 days from notice Post-trial motions15 days
Appeal Time to appeal30 days Time to appeal30 days from notice of entry Time to appeal60 days from notice of entry Time to appeal30 days