Glossary

The language of the docket

229 terms from court filings, rulings and hearings, in plain English. Where federal, New York, California or Florida courts do things differently, the entry says so. To see where the terms fall in a lawsuit, read the anatomy of a civil case.

Reading one docket entry

Illustrative — invented parties
131 206/09/2025 3MOTION to Dismiss the Amended Complaint under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6). 4Document filed by Acme Holdings LLC. 5(Attachments: # 1 Memorandum of Law, # 2 Declaration of A. Smith, # 3 Exhibit A) 6(Smith, Alan) (Entered: 06/09/2025)
32 06/12/2025 ORDER scheduling briefing on 31 Motion to Dismiss. Opposition due 7/11/2025. SO ORDERED.
  1. Entry number. Cited as “ECF No. 31”. Entries are numbered in the order filed.
  2. Filing date. Not always the date a judge acted.
  3. The kind of paper. Capital letters usually name the filing type. Look for “motion”, “order”, “proposed order”.
  4. Who filed it. The filer, not necessarily the party the paper is about.
  5. Attachments. Supporting declarations and exhibits that ride along with the entry.
  6. Filer and entry date. The lawyer who filed it and when the clerk entered it.

Start with these ten

  1. 01 Docket The court’s running list of everything that happens in a case.
  2. 02 Allegation A statement of fact in a court filing that the party has not yet proved.
  3. 03 Motion to dismiss Asks the court to end some or all of the claims at the start, without a trial, by arguing they are legally defective.
  4. 04 Motion for summary judgment Asks the court to decide a claim, or the whole case, without a trial because the facts that matter are not genuinely disputed.
  5. 05 Order to show cause An order that requires someone to explain, in writing or in person, why the court should not do something.
  6. 06 Proposed order A draft order that a party submits for the judge to sign.
  7. 07 With prejudice and without prejudice “With prejudice” means the dismissal is final and the claim cannot be brought again.
  8. 08 Motion in limine A motion made before or during trial asking the judge to rule in advance on whether certain evidence may be shown to the jury.
  9. 09 Sealed A document kept from the public by court order.
  10. 10 Motion to withdraw as counsel A lawyer’s request for permission to stop representing a client.
01

Reading the docket

The vocabulary of the docket itself: numbers, captions, entries, and the systems that publish them.

The court’s running list of everything that happens in a case. Each filing, order and hearing gets its own numbered, dated entry, in the order it occurred.

Read more

“Docket” is also used for the case itself (“the case is on Judge Smith’s docket”) and for a court’s calendar. A docket entry is a clerk’s summary; the document it points to is the actual filing.

See alsoDocket entryCase numberPACER

One line on the docket: a number, a filing date, a short description of the paper, and who filed it.

More

The description is written by the filer or a clerk and can be incomplete or wrong. Attachments are listed with the entry that carries them. A missing number can mean a sealed document.

See alsoECF No.SealedExhibit

The identifier a court assigns when a case opens. Every filing carries it, and it is the surest way to find one case among thousands.

More

A federal number such as 1:24-cv-01457 reads: courthouse or division, year, type (cv civil, cr criminal), sequence. A California number such as 25SMCV05091 reads: year, courthouse code, case type, sequence. Florida numbers lead with the year and end with a division. An appeal gets a new number in the appeals court.

See alsoIndex numberCaption

New York’s version of a case number, assigned when the first papers are filed and bought from the county clerk. Written as sequence/year, such as 151935/2025.

More

The index number stays with a case through its life in that county’s Supreme Court. An appeal to the Appellate Division is given its own number.

See alsoCase numberSupreme Court (New York)

The heading of a filing: the court, the parties’ names, the case number and the title of the document.

More

Captions are edited over time as parties are added or dropped, and a shortened case name (“Doe v. Roe, et al.”) usually lists only the first party on each side. A pseudonym in the caption is the name the court is using, not necessarily the person’s own.

See alsoDoeEt al.

ECF No.

Federal

The number of an entry on a federal docket, as cited in briefs and opinions: “ECF No. 42” or “Dkt. 42”. Attachments take a suffix, such as 42-1.

More

ECF stands for Electronic Case Filing. Citations to a page usually follow the number: “ECF No. 42 at 7”.

See alsoPACERDocket entry

PACER

Federal

The federal courts’ online system for dockets and documents. It charges per page, with a cap per document, and opinions are free.

More

RECAP and CourtListener, run by the Free Law Project, keep a free public archive of documents that PACER users have already bought.

See alsoECF No.

NYSCEF

N.Y.

New York’s e-filing system. Most civil cases in New York’s trial courts are filed there, and each paper gets a “Doc. No.” on a public docket.

More

Some case types are not public, and a judge can seal documents. A motion carries a sequence number that ties its papers together.

See alsoMotion sequence numberIndex number

A number NYSCEF gives each motion in a case (“Motion Seq. 002”) so the motion, its opposition, its reply and the ruling can be matched.

More

A sequence number is used whether or not the motion is argued. Use it to follow one motion through a crowded docket.

See alsoNYSCEFReturn date

A document kept from the public by court order. The docket may show an entry that reads only “Sealed Document”, or show nothing at all.

Illustrative docket text57 | 11/03/2025 | Sealed Document: Order. Document filed by Court. (Entered: 11/03/2025)
Read more

Courts start from a presumption that filings are public, so sealing needs a stated reason, such as protecting a minor, a trade secret or an investigation. A party usually has to ask for it with a motion to seal.

See alsoRedactionMotion to seal

Redaction

Federal

Blacking out part of a public filing while leaving the rest visible.

More

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2 requires filers to redact Social Security numbers to the last four digits, birth dates to the year, financial account numbers to the last four digits, and minors’ names to initials.

See alsoSealed

A document attached to a filing as support, labeled by letter or number (Exhibit A, Ex. 12).

More

A docket entry for a motion often lists its exhibits as attachments, so the exhibit may be a contract, a text message or a transcript. Reading a motion without the exhibits gives half the picture.

See alsoDeclarationDocket entry

A clerk’s note of what happened at a hearing: who appeared, what was argued, what the judge decided from the bench.

More

A minute entry can itself be the order. If so, there is no separate PDF, and the text on the docket is the whole ruling.

See alsoBench rulingEndorsement

The word-for-word record of a hearing, trial or deposition, prepared by a court reporter.

More

Transcripts are ordered and paid for separately. They usually reach the docket days or weeks after the hearing, and may be redacted first.

See alsoCourt reporterDeposition

02

People & roles

Who is who on a docket, from the party names in the caption to the lawyers and judges signing the papers.

The person or company that starts a civil lawsuit and asks the court for relief.

More

In a criminal case no one is called a plaintiff. The government is the prosecution, and the person charged is the defendant. On appeal the labels change again.

See alsoDefendantAppellant and appellee

The person or company being sued, or in a criminal case, being prosecuted.

More

A complaint can name many. “Co-defendants” are those sued in the same case. They can have different lawyers and conflicting interests.

See alsoPlaintiffDoe

Doe

A placeholder name. A Jane Doe or John Doe plaintiff is a real person whose name is withheld. A Doe defendant is someone the plaintiff cannot yet identify.

More

A plaintiff usually needs the court’s permission to proceed anonymously, and the court balances privacy against the public’s interest in open proceedings. “Does 1–10” in a caption reserves a place for unknown defendants, who can be named later once they are identified.

See alsoMotion for leave to proceed under a pseudonymCaption

Someone who is not named in the case but is affected by it or holds information the case needs.

More

A non-party can be served with a subpoena, can ask to intervene, or can ask to unseal documents. Non-party companies often appear on a docket only when they receive a subpoena.

See alsoSubpoenaMotion to intervene

The lawyers who have formally appeared for a party and are listed on the docket. Court papers are served on them.

More

“Lead counsel” directs the case. “Of counsel” is an affiliated lawyer who is not a partner. Counsel of record stays so until the case ends or the court allows a change.

See alsoNotice of appearanceMotion to withdraw as counsel

A short filing in which a lawyer announces that they now represent a party.

More

It adds the lawyer to the docket and the service list. In New York a notice of appearance can also be the defendant’s first response, before an answer.

See alsoCounsel of record

Representing oneself in court without a lawyer. Pronounced “pro SAY”.

More

Individuals may appear pro se. In federal court a corporation or LLC generally may not, and has to be represented by a lawyer.

See alsoCounsel of record

Latin for “for this occasion”. It describes a lawyer licensed elsewhere who is admitted to appear in one case.

More

The lawyer usually must associate with local counsel who signs the papers. A motion to appear pro hac vice is a routine early entry on a docket.

See alsoCounsel of record

District judge

Federal

A federal trial judge with a lifetime appointment. Handles the case from filing through trial, including major rulings.

More

A federal case is assigned to one district judge, often shown by initials after the case number. Individual practices set that judge’s own rules for letters, page limits and conferences.

See alsoMagistrate judgeIndividual practices

A federal judge who handles part of a case under a district judge: discovery disputes, settlement conferences, some motions and, with consent, whole trials.

More

On major motions a magistrate judge may issue a report and recommendation, which the district judge reviews.

See alsoReport and recommendationDistrict judge

The title for a trial judge of New York’s Supreme Court, which is the state’s main trial court despite the name.

More

Each justice presides over a Part and is addressed as “Justice”. An appellate judge is also a justice. Judges of the state’s other courts are called “Judge”.

See alsoSupreme Court (New York)Part

A judge’s office and staff, including law clerks. “Chambers” also refers to what the judge has said informally, as in “chambers’ rules”.

More

Chambers is where a letter or proposed order is sent when a judge’s individual practices ask for one.

The court officer whose staff accepts filings, maintains the docket, issues summonses and enters judgments.

More

A clerk does not decide anything. A clerk’s entry of default, for example, is a ministerial act. A judge decides what follows.

See alsoDefault

The person who takes down a hearing or deposition word for word and produces the transcript.

More

A court reporter is also called a stenographer. Transcripts can be ordered in expedited form.

See alsoTranscript

A person appointed by the court to protect the interests of a minor or someone who cannot manage their own case.

More

Settlements involving a minor generally need court approval for that reason.

AUSA

Federal

Assistant United States Attorney. The federal prosecutor assigned to a case, working for the U.S. Attorney of that district.

More

Federal prosecutions in Manhattan are brought by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York. The prosecutor signs the filings and argues in court.

See alsoIndictmentS.D.N.Y.

A fact witness describes what they saw or did. An expert witness gives opinions based on specialized knowledge and may be paid.

More

Experts file written reports in advance, and the other side may challenge them. A subpoena can compel a fact witness to testify.

See alsoDaubert motionSubpoena

03

Courts & jurisdiction

Where a case lives and why. The same words mean different things in federal, New York, California and Florida courts.

A court’s power to hear a case. A court needs power over the subject (subject-matter jurisdiction) and over the defendant (personal jurisdiction).

More

A ruling by a court without jurisdiction can be thrown out, so courts check early. Either defect can be raised in a motion to dismiss.

See alsoSubject-matter jurisdictionPersonal jurisdiction

Whether a court is allowed to decide this kind of dispute. A federal court generally needs a question of federal law or parties from different states.

More

The two federal routes are federal-question jurisdiction (28 U.S.C. § 1331) and diversity jurisdiction (§ 1332), which also requires more than $75,000 at stake. Federal courts can hear related state-law claims alongside a federal one.

See alsoMotion to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdictionRemoval

Whether the person bringing a case has been injured in a way the court can fix.

More

Federal standing requires an injury, caused by the defendant, that a ruling could remedy. A plaintiff without standing is dismissed no matter how strong the claim.

Which of the courts that could hear a case is the right place for it, usually based on where the defendant lives or where events occurred.

More

A party that thinks the case is in the wrong or an inconvenient place can move to transfer it. A venue fight can move a case across the country.

See alsoMotion to transfer venue

Removal

Federal

A defendant’s move of a case from state court to federal court, started by filing a notice of removal in the federal court.

More

Removal generally must be filed within 30 days of service (28 U.S.C. § 1446). The plaintiff can respond with a motion to remand. Docket numbers change: the case gets a federal number and the state case is closed or marked removed.

See alsoMotion to remand

S.D.N.Y.

Federal

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York: the federal trial court for Manhattan, the Bronx, and six counties to the north.

More

Appeals go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. “E.D.N.Y.” is the Eastern District (Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Long Island).

See alsoCircuit court of appeals

In New York, the Supreme Court is the main state trial court, not the highest. The highest is the Court of Appeals.

Read more

New York County Supreme Court sits in Manhattan. Cases there are filed through NYSCEF, assigned to a Justice and a Part, and appealed to the Appellate Division.

See alsoAppellate DivisionNYSCEFJustice (New York)

Part

N.Y.

A courtroom and the justice assigned to it in New York’s Supreme Court (“Part 48”). Each Part has its own rules.

More

Part rules can say how to request a conference, when to file letters, or how motions are argued, and they override general practice.

See alsoJustice (New York)Individual practices

A branch of New York’s Supreme Court for business disputes above a monetary threshold, with its own rules and judges.

More

The threshold varies by county. Commercial Division rules, for example on page limits, are separate from the Part rules.

See alsoPart

California’s trial court, organized by county. The Los Angeles Superior Court (LASC) hears civil cases in courthouses across the county.

More

The courthouse code in a case number (SM for Santa Monica, ST for Stanley Mosk) shows where the case was filed. Appeals go to the California Court of Appeal.

See alsoCase number

Florida’s general trial court for larger civil cases and felonies, organized in judicial circuits. Miami-Dade County is the Eleventh Judicial Circuit.

More

Appeals from Miami-Dade go to the Third District Court of Appeal.

A judge’s own written rules, posted on the court’s website, covering how to write to chambers, when a letter must come before a motion, page limits and how to schedule conferences.

More

They differ from judge to judge and override the court’s general local rules where they conflict. If something on a docket looks odd, the individual practices often explain it.

See alsoPre-motion letterRules of procedure

04

Starting a case

The papers that open a lawsuit and the first replies to them.

The document that starts a civil lawsuit. It names the parties, lays out the facts the plaintiff alleges, lists the legal claims and says what relief is requested.

More

A federal case begins when the complaint is filed. In New York a case can begin with a summons with notice, with the complaint following. A criminal “complaint” is a different document.

See alsoAllegationCause of actionSummons

A statement of fact in a court filing that the party has not yet proved.

Read more

Everything in a complaint is an allegation. On a motion to dismiss, a court assumes the allegations are true only to decide whether they would state a claim. That assumption is not a finding. A case ending without a ruling on the facts says nothing about whether they were true.

See alsoComplaintMotion to dismiss

A court-issued notice that tells the defendant a case has been filed and how long they have to respond.

More

A defendant who ignores a properly served summons risks default. The summons is served together with the complaint.

See alsoService of processDefault

In New York, a way to start a case with a short summons stating the nature of the claim and the relief sought, with the full complaint to come later.

More

A defendant can demand the complaint. The next step is then served on the defendant’s lawyer.

See alsoComplaint

In New York, the form that asks the court to assign a judge to a new case. Until it is filed, there is no judge and no way to make a motion.

More

RJI is the usual abbreviation. Its filing date is often the first sign that the case is moving.

See alsoJustice (New York)

Formally delivering the summons and complaint to the defendant so they have notice. A defendant’s response deadline starts only after service.

More

The default time to serve is 90 days from filing in federal court (Rule 4(m)), 120 days in New York (CPLR 306-b), and proof of service is due within 60 days in California. A defendant can agree to waive formal service, which gives 60 days to respond in federal court.

See alsoAffidavit of serviceSummons

A sworn statement, usually by the process server, saying when, where and how the papers were delivered.

More

It is the court’s evidence that the defendant was served. A defect in service is a common reason for a motion to dismiss.

See alsoService of process

The defendant’s written response to a complaint, which admits or denies each allegation and lists defenses.

More

The usual deadline is 21 days from service in federal court, 20 or 30 days in New York depending on how the defendant was served, 30 days in California and 20 days in Florida. Lawyers often agree to extend, and a motion to dismiss usually pauses the clock.

See alsoAffirmative defenseDefault

A defense that says that even if the plaintiff’s facts are true, the defendant should still win, such as the statute of limitations, consent or release.

More

The defendant bears the burden of proving it. Defenses not raised in the answer can be treated as waived.

See alsoStatute of limitationsAnswer

A claim by a defendant against the plaintiff in the same case.

More

A counterclaim that arises from the same events as the complaint generally must be brought in that case or is lost. The plaintiff answers it, and it can be dismissed separately.

See alsoCross-claim

A claim by one defendant against another defendant in the same case, or by a plaintiff against a co-plaintiff.

More

Cross-claims often seek indemnification or contribution.

See alsoIndemnification and contribution

A defendant’s claim that a non-party should be made to pay some or all of what the defendant owes the plaintiff.

More

The new party is then called a third-party defendant. Federal courts call the procedure impleader.

See alsoIndemnification and contribution

A revised complaint that replaces the original. It can add claims, drop others or name new defendants.

More

A plaintiff can amend once without permission in a short window after filing or after the defendant’s first response, and after that needs the other side’s consent or the court’s leave. A new complaint often moots a pending motion to dismiss.

See alsoMotion for leave

A written request for a jury trial. Without a timely one, the right to a jury can be waived and a judge decides the case.

More

Often a line at the end of the complaint. The jury right applies to many but not all kinds of claims.

See alsoBench trial and jury trial

The part of the complaint that lists what the plaintiff wants: damages, an injunction, fees, interest.

More

Also called the demand for relief or the “wherefore” clause. New York bars a dollar figure in personal-injury complaints (CPLR 3017(c)), so complaints there often ask for damages “in an amount to be determined at trial”.

See alsoDamages

05

Claims & theories

The legal labels attached to what a complaint alleges. A claim in a complaint is an allegation, not a finding.

A legal theory plus the facts alleged to support it, such as battery or breach of contract. Federal courts say “claim”, and each is numbered as a count.

More

A complaint with seven counts alleges seven theories, often arising from the same events. A court can dismiss some counts and keep others.

See alsoComplaint

In a civil case, intentionally touching someone in a harmful or offensive way without consent.

More

California separately recognizes sexual battery in its Civil Code. In New York the ordinary limitations period for battery is one year, which is why revival laws matter.

See alsoRevival windowAssault

In a civil case, intentionally causing someone to reasonably fear imminent harmful contact.

More

Civil assault does not require touching. In everyday speech “assault” covers both, but a complaint usually lists assault and battery as two counts.

See alsoBattery

Intentionally confining someone against their will, with no lawful authority.

More

Confinement can be physical or by threat, and does not require locked doors.

Extreme and outrageous conduct that intentionally or recklessly causes severe emotional distress. Abbreviated IIED.

More

Courts set a high bar for “outrageous” conduct, and a count of this kind is often challenged in a motion to dismiss.

Failing to use reasonable care so that someone is harmed. The plaintiff must show a duty, a breach of it, causation and damages.

More

Unlike battery, negligence does not require intent. It is the basis for claims against employers, property owners and others who did not themselves cause the harm.

See alsoNegligent hiring, retention and supervisionPremises liability

A claim that an employer or organization failed to act on a known or foreseeable risk posed by someone it hired, kept or supervised.

More

The claim is against the employer for its own carelessness, not for the employee’s act. It usually depends on what the employer knew and when.

See alsoVicarious liabilityNegligence

A claim that a property owner or operator failed to keep a place reasonably safe, including from foreseeable harm by others.

More

Claims against hotels, clubs and event venues often take this form. The question is usually what the property knew or should have known.

See alsoNegligence

Responsibility of one person for another’s wrong, most often an employer for what an employee does within the scope of the job.

More

Also called respondeat superior. Whether conduct falls within the scope of employment is a recurring dispute.

See alsoNegligent hiring, retention and supervision

A claim that two or more people agreed to commit a wrong, so each is responsible for it.

More

In New York it is not a stand-alone claim. It only ties defendants to an underlying wrong, which must itself be alleged and proved.

See alsoAiding and abetting

A claim that a defendant knowingly gave substantial help to someone else’s wrong.

More

The plaintiff must plead the primary wrong and the defendant’s knowledge. Courts often dismiss these claims for thin allegations of knowledge.

See alsoCivil conspiracy

A false statement of fact, communicated to others, that harms someone’s reputation. Written is libel and spoken is slander.

More

Truth is a defense. A public figure must also show the speaker acted with “actual malice”, meaning knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth. Opinions are generally protected.

See alsoAnti-SLAPP motion

A claim that someone failed to do what a contract required.

More

The elements are a contract, the plaintiff’s performance, the defendant’s breach and damages. Disputes often turn on exactly what the contract says, so it is typically filed as an exhibit.

A claim that someone knowingly made a false statement, on which the plaintiff reasonably relied, causing loss.

More

Federal courts require fraud to be pleaded with particularity (Rule 9(b)): who said what, when and why it was false.

A claim that the defendant got a benefit that it would be unfair to keep, even without a contract.

More

Often added as a fallback to a contract claim.

A theory that a company is so controlled by its owner that the law should disregard the separation, making the owner liable for the company’s obligations. Also “piercing the corporate veil”.

More

Courts pierce rarely. The plaintiff generally must show domination of the company and that the company form was used to commit a wrong.

See alsoJoint and several liability

A rule that lets a plaintiff collect a whole judgment from any one liable defendant, who then seeks repayment from the others.

More

New York limits it for non-economic damages when a defendant is 50 percent or less at fault, with exceptions.

See alsoIndemnification and contribution

A court’s declaration of the parties’ rights, with no damages awarded, used to settle a dispute before harm is done.

More

Common in contract and insurance disputes.

06

Motions

Requests to the court. The kind of motion shows what is being asked and where in the case it usually appears.

A formal written request asking the court to rule on something.

More

The party asking is the movant. The other side opposes, the movant replies, and the judge rules on the papers or after argument. A motion is not a finding of anything.

See alsoNotice of motionOpposition and replyFully briefed

The cover paper that tells the court and the parties what is being asked, on what grounds and, in many courts, the date the motion will be heard.

More

In New York it states the return date. It is followed by the supporting papers.

See alsoReturn date

A written legal argument in support of or against a motion, setting out the facts and the rules and cases relied on. Also called a brief.

More

California calls it a memorandum of points and authorities. Judges set page limits for it.

A written statement of facts signed under penalty of perjury, filed with a motion as evidence.

More

An affidavit is the same idea, sworn before a notary. New York lets anyone use a sworn “affirmation” instead (CPLR 2106). Declarations are how evidence reaches a judge without a hearing.

See alsoExhibit

The opposition is the other side’s response to a motion. The reply is the movant’s answer to it.

More

Deadlines are set by local rule or the judge, and a reply often cannot raise new arguments. When all three are on the docket, the motion is fully briefed.

See alsoFully briefed

Every paper has been filed, and the motion is ready for the judge to decide.

More

A ruling can follow in days or take months. Federal courts publicly report motions that have been pending more than six months.

A motion filed in response to another motion in the same briefing round, often asking for the opposite result.

More

The court then decides both together. A party can oppose a motion for summary judgment and cross-move for the same relief.

The date on which a motion is to be heard or submitted for decision.

More

In New York it is printed on the notice of motion. Other papers are due a set number of days before it.

See alsoNotice of motion

A short letter to the judge, required by some judges’ individual practices, outlining a planned motion before it is filed.

More

The judge can set a schedule, hold a conference or discourage the motion. In the Southern District of New York, discovery disputes also start with a letter (Local Civil Rule 37.2).

See alsoIndividual practicesLetter motion

Letter motion

Federal

A request made by letter, not formal motion papers. Used for scheduling, extensions and small issues.

More

A letter motion is a motion even though it is short. The judge may answer on the letter itself.

See alsoEndorsement

Asks the court to end some or all of the claims at the start, without a trial, by arguing they are legally defective.

Illustrative docket text31 | 06/09/2025 | MOTION to Dismiss the Amended Complaint under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6). Document filed by Acme Holdings LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Memorandum of Law, # 2 Declaration of A. Smith, # 3 Exhibit A)
Read more

The main federal grounds are in Rule 12(b): lack of jurisdiction, improper venue, defective service and failure to state a claim. New York uses CPLR 3211, and California uses a demurrer. A dismissal can be with or without prejudice, and often comes with leave to amend.

See alsoFailure to state a claimDemurrerCPLR 3211 motionWith prejudice and without prejudice

The usual ground for a federal motion to dismiss (Rule 12(b)(6)): even if every fact in the complaint is true, the law gives no remedy.

More

The court takes the complaint’s allegations as true, but not legal conclusions, and asks whether the facts make the claim plausible. It does not weigh evidence or decide who is right.

See alsoAllegationMotion to dismiss

Demurrer

Calif.

California’s version of a motion to dismiss. It argues that even on the complaint’s own facts there is no valid claim.

More

If the judge sustains the demurrer, it is granted. If overruled, it is denied. Many are “sustained with leave to amend”, giving the plaintiff a chance to fix the complaint. Florida and New York do not use demurrers.

See alsoMotion to dismissWith prejudice and without prejudice

New York’s motion to dismiss, brought under CPLR 3211(a) before the answer. Each lettered ground is a separate reason.

More

Subsection (a)(5) is the statute of limitations, (a)(7) is failure to state a claim, (a)(1) is documentary evidence, and (a)(8) is lack of personal jurisdiction.

See alsoMotion to dismiss

A motion made after the answer, asking for judgment because the pleadings alone show who wins.

More

Federal courts treat it much like a motion to dismiss. California has the same motion.

See alsoMotion to dismiss

Asks the court to remove part of a filing as redundant, immaterial or scandalous.

More

Federal courts rarely grant it. It is most often used for allegations that have no bearing on the claims.

See alsoAnti-SLAPP motion

Anti-SLAPP motion

N.Y.Calif.

An early motion to dismiss a claim that targets speech on a public issue. SLAPP stands for Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation.

More

New York (CPLR 3211(g) and Civil Rights Law § 70-a) and California (Code Civ. Proc. § 425.16, called a special motion to strike) have anti-SLAPP laws. A defendant who wins can recover legal fees.

See alsoDefamationAttorney’s fees

Asks the court to decide a claim, or the whole case, without a trial because the facts that matter are not genuinely disputed.

Illustrative docket text118 | 02/04/2026 | MOTION for Summary Judgment. Document filed by Jane Roe. (Attachments: # 1 Statement of Undisputed Material Facts, # 2 Memorandum of Law, # 3 Declaration of J. Roe, # 4 Exhibit 1 - Deposition Transcript)
Read more

Unlike a motion to dismiss, it relies on evidence (depositions, documents, declarations), so it comes after discovery. The judge views the evidence in the light most favorable to the party opposing it. “Partial” summary judgment decides some claims or issues only. Governed by Rule 56, CPLR 3212 and Code Civ. Proc. § 437c.

See alsoDiscoveryDeclaration

Asks the court to undo an earlier order, judgment or default.

More

Rule 60(b) lists the reasons, such as mistake, newly discovered evidence or fraud, with deadlines. New York uses CPLR 5015 and California Code Civ. Proc. § 473(b).

See alsoDefaultJudgment

Asks the same judge to take another look at a ruling. Also called a motion to reargue.

More

The standard is strict: the judge overlooked controlling law or facts, not that the loser disagrees. In New York a motion to reargue (CPLR 2221(d)) differs from a motion to renew (2221(e)), which relies on new facts. Short deadlines apply.

See alsoMotion to vacate

Asks the court to order the other side to respond to discovery or to answer a deposition question.

More

Courts expect the parties to try to resolve it first, which is why the papers say they “met and conferred”.

See alsoMeet and conferDiscovery

Asks the court to cancel a subpoena, often because it is too broad, burdensome or seeks privileged material.

More

It is often brought by a non-party who received the subpoena.

See alsoSubpoenaNon-party

Asks the court to keep a document or part of one out of the public file.

More

Courts begin with a presumption of public access and ask for reasons. Redaction is often favored over sealing a whole document.

See alsoSealedRedaction

Asks the court to let a plaintiff use a fictitious name, such as Jane Doe, because disclosure would cause harm.

More

The court weighs the plaintiff’s privacy against the public’s interest in open proceedings and fairness to the defendant. A court’s ruling is separate from the merits.

See alsoDoe

Asks the court’s permission to do something that cannot be done as of right: amend a complaint, file late, file a longer brief.

More

Rule 15(a)(2) says leave to amend should be “freely” given when justice requires.

See alsoAmended complaint

Asks the court to pause a case, or part of it, while something else happens, such as an appeal, a related case or settlement talks.

More

A stay is not a dismissal. The case waits and then resumes.

See alsoStay

Asks the court to join related cases for pretrial work, for trial, or for both.

More

Consolidation (Rule 42(a), CPLR 602) does not merge the cases into one claim set. Each keeps its own parties and result. California can coordinate similar cases from different courts (Code Civ. Proc. § 404).

See alsoCase number

Asks the court to move the case to another court, usually for convenience.

More

In federal court it is brought under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a), and a judge looks at where the witnesses and documents are.

See alsoVenue

Asks a federal court to send a removed case back to state court because it should not have come.

More

Remand motions are often decided quickly. A removing party without a reasonable basis can be ordered to pay the other side’s fees.

See alsoRemoval

Asks to join an existing case as a party because the ruling will affect the movant’s interests. Rule 24.

More

News organizations sometimes intervene for the narrow purpose of asking the court to unseal documents.

See alsoNon-partySealed

A lawyer’s request for permission to stop representing a client. Once a lawyer has appeared, they generally cannot leave without the court’s approval.

Illustrative docket text124 | 10/05/2026 | MOTION to Withdraw as Attorney. Document filed by Smith & Jones LLP. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Counsel, # 2 Proposed Order)
Read more

Courts want a showing of satisfactory reasons and weigh the effect on the schedule. Federal Local Civil Rule 1.4 in S.D.N.Y. and CPLR 321(b) in New York set the rules. The reasons are sometimes given to the judge in camera. A company cannot appear without a lawyer in federal court, so the court may give it time to find one. A lawyer can keep a lien on the client’s file and on any recovery.

See alsoRetaining lien and charging lienPro seCounsel of record

Asks the court to penalize a party or lawyer for improper conduct: a frivolous filing, a discovery violation or bad faith.

More

Rule 11 requires the movant to serve the motion first and wait 21 days so the other side can withdraw the offending paper. California has the same safe harbor (Code Civ. Proc. § 128.7). New York’s rule on frivolous conduct is 22 NYCRR Part 130.

See alsoSpoliation

Asks the court to send a dispute to arbitration because the parties agreed in a contract to arbitrate.

More

If granted, the court case is usually stayed. See the entry for arbitration.

See alsoArbitration

A motion made before or during trial asking the judge to rule in advance on whether certain evidence may be shown to the jury. Pronounced “in LIM-in-ee”, Latin for “at the threshold”.

Illustrative docket text212 | 03/02/2026 | MOTION in Limine to Preclude Evidence of Prior Acts. Document filed by Defendant. (Attachments: # 1 Memorandum of Law, # 2 Exhibit A)
Read more

It lets lawyers keep prejudicial material from the jury before it is heard. A ruling is provisional and can change at trial. A defendant might move in limine to bar evidence of earlier incidents, and a plaintiff might move to admit it.

See alsoRule 403Rule 404(b)Rules 413–415

A motion to exclude an expert witness because the expert’s method is not reliable or does not fit the issues.

More

Named for a 1993 U.S. Supreme Court case and now governed by Federal Rule of Evidence 702, under which the judge acts as gatekeeper. New York’s courts follow the older Frye test, which asks whether the method is generally accepted in the field.

See alsoWitness (fact and expert)

07

Orders & rulings

What the court says back, and what the words in a ruling actually decide.

A written direction from the court. It can decide a motion, set a schedule or tell someone to do or not do something.

More

An order is binding when signed and entered. A proposed order is not.

See alsoProposed orderOpinion and order

A draft order that a party submits for the judge to sign. It is not an order until the judge signs it.

Illustrative docket text124-2 | (PROPOSED) ORDER granting 124 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. Document filed by Smith & Jones LLP. Related Doc. # 124
Read more

Many courts want one attached to a motion, and the judge may sign it, change it or reject it. Because it is written by one side, it shows what that side asked for, not what the court decided. Look for the signed version, which often has the same title without the word “proposed”.

See alsoOrderOrder to show cause

An order that requires someone to explain, in writing or in person, why the court should not do something. Abbreviated OSC. Pronounced as written.

Illustrative docket text1 | PROPOSED ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE (Motion Seq. 002). Return date to be set by the Court. Document filed by Plaintiff.
Read more

In federal court the judge issues it, often when a party has missed a deadline or may face sanctions or dismissal. Being ordered to show cause is not a ruling against the party. In New York a lawyer can start a motion this way (CPLR 2214(d)): the lawyer submits papers and a proposed order, and if the judge signs it, the order sets the schedule. It is used when the matter is urgent or interim relief is wanted.

See alsoProposed orderMotionStay

A ruling with written reasoning. Federal courts often title it “Opinion & Order”, and New York courts “Decision and Order”.

More

Opinions explain how the judge applied the law. Short rulings that only grant or deny are sometimes called short-form orders.

See alsoOrderEndorsement

A decision announced orally in the courtroom, often on the record at a hearing.

More

The reasons then appear in the transcript, and a short minute entry may be all the docket shows. A written order may follow.

See alsoMinute entryTranscript

A judge’s handwritten or typed ruling placed on a party’s own letter or proposed order, usually ending “SO ORDERED”.

More

On a federal docket it may be titled “Memo Endorsement” or “Endorsed Letter”. The answer and the original request are in the same document, so read both.

See alsoLetter motionMinute entry

An order setting the deadlines in a case: amended pleadings, discovery, motions and trial.

More

Federal Rule 16(b) calls for one early. In New York the equivalent is set at the preliminary conference. Deadlines can be extended only for good cause.

See alsoPreliminary conferenceDiscovery

In New York, an early meeting at which the judge or court attorney sets the discovery schedule.

More

The order that results is called a preliminary conference order. The case management conference serves the same purpose in California, and the initial pretrial conference in federal court.

See alsoScheduling order

A magistrate judge’s proposed decision on a motion or case, sent to the district judge to adopt, change or reject.

More

A party has 14 days to file written objections. The district judge then reviews the parts objected to.

See alsoMagistrate judge

The two outcomes for a motion. “Granted in part and denied in part” is common.

More

A denial “without prejudice” leaves the door open to try again. “As moot” means events made the motion unnecessary. A grant can come “with leave to amend”.

See alsoWith prejudice and without prejudice

“With prejudice” means the dismissal is final and the claim cannot be brought again. “Without prejudice” means it can.

Read more

When an order is silent, federal Rule 41(b) treats most involuntary dismissals as with prejudice, except those for lack of jurisdiction, improper venue or failure to join a party. Courts usually say which they mean, so read the order for the words.

See alsoMotion to dismissVoluntary dismissal

An order pausing all or part of a case.

More

A stay can be temporary, such as 30 days to let a party find new counsel, or can last until something else is decided. A stay ends by its own terms or by further order.

See alsoMotion to stay

A court order to do something or stop doing something. A temporary restraining order (TRO) is short and quick, a preliminary injunction lasts through the case, and a permanent injunction comes with the final judgment.

More

A party asking for one generally must show a likelihood of success, irreparable harm and that fairness and the public interest favor relief. A federal TRO issued without notice expires after 14 days unless extended (Rule 65(b)).

See alsoOrder to show cause

An order that limits discovery or controls how confidential material is used. A confidentiality order lets parties mark documents “Confidential” and restricts who sees them.

More

Rule 26(c) allows one for good cause. A protective order does not by itself seal anything in the public file.

See alsoSealedDiscovery

An agreement signed by the parties that the judge also signs, giving it the force of an order.

More

Also called a so-ordered stipulation. Common for extensions, scheduling and confidentiality terms.

See alsoVoluntary dismissal

An order limiting what parties, lawyers or witnesses may say publicly about a case.

More

Courts weigh it against the First Amendment and the defendant’s right to a fair trial. It is typically narrow.

Latin for “on its own”. It describes something the judge does without anyone asking.

More

A judge may dismiss, order a conference or raise a jurisdiction question sua sponte.

08

Evidence & discovery

How each side finds out what the other has, and what a jury is allowed to hear.

The stage in which each side obtains evidence from the other and from outsiders, before trial.

More

The tools are interrogatories, document requests, depositions, requests for admission and subpoenas. A judge intervenes only when there is a dispute. Federal Rule 26 sets the scope: relevant to a claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case.

See alsoInterrogatoriesRequest for productionDepositionRequest for admission

A requirement that lawyers talk, and try to settle a discovery dispute, before asking a judge to decide it.

More

A motion to compel or for a protective order must say that it happened.

See alsoMotion to compel

Written questions that one party sends the other, to be answered under oath.

More

Federal rules cap them at 25 per party, including subparts, unless the court allows more.

See alsoRequest for production

A written demand that the other side produce documents, messages, recordings or objects.

More

In New York it is called a notice for discovery and inspection. The response either produces or objects.

See alsoPrivilege

A written request to admit that a fact is true or a document is genuine.

More

In federal court a request not answered within 30 days is treated as admitted (Rule 36).

Sworn testimony given out of court, answering lawyers’ questions, with a court reporter taking it down.

More

The transcript can be used in a motion for summary judgment, to challenge a witness at trial, or in lieu of live testimony. Federal depositions are generally limited to one day of seven hours. New York calls it an examination before trial (EBT).

See alsoTranscriptMotion for summary judgment

A court-issued command to testify (ad testificandum) or to bring documents (duces tecum).

More

Lawyers can issue subpoenas in federal cases. A non-party who receives one can comply, negotiate or move to quash.

See alsoMotion to quash

A legal protection that lets a party withhold information. Attorney–client privilege covers confidential legal advice, and work-product protection covers materials prepared for litigation.

More

A party that withholds documents lists them on a privilege log. The log shows what exists without revealing the contents, and challenges are decided by the judge, sometimes in camera.

See alsoIn camera

Destroying or failing to preserve evidence that should have been kept for a case.

More

Sanctions range from fees to an adverse inference, which tells the jury it may assume the missing evidence was unfavorable.

See alsoMotion for sanctions

A court’s acceptance of a fact as true without requiring proof, because it is beyond reasonable dispute.

More

Under Federal Rule of Evidence 201, examples are a court’s own docket and well-known historical facts. The court may notice that a document was filed, but not that its contents are true.

An out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of what it says. Generally not admissible, with many exceptions.

More

The rule is about why the statement is offered. A statement offered only to show it was made, or its effect on a listener, is not hearsay.

Federal Rule of Evidence 403: relevant evidence can be excluded if its value is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, confusion, delay or waste of time.

More

A routine basis for motions in limine.

Rule 404(b)

Federal

Federal Rule of Evidence 404(b): evidence of other acts cannot be used to show that someone acted the same way again, but may be used for other purposes, such as motive, intent, plan or knowledge.

More

Prosecutors must give notice before trial of what they intend to offer. The judge decides whether each use is proper and whether Rule 403 excludes it. Often fought through motions in limine.

See alsoRule 403Motion in limine

Rules 413–415

Federal

Federal Rules of Evidence 413, 414 and 415 let courts admit evidence of a defendant’s other sexual assaults in sexual-assault cases. Rule 415 applies in civil cases.

More

They are exceptions to the general ban on propensity evidence, and Rule 403 still applies. A court decides case by case.

See alsoRule 404(b)

Who must prove something, and how convincingly.

Read more

In most civil cases the plaintiff must show a claim is more likely true than not (preponderance of the evidence). Some claims require clear and convincing evidence. In a criminal case the government must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, a much higher bar, which is why the same events can produce different results in criminal and civil courts.

See alsoVerdictCollateral estoppel

09

Trial & criminal cases

The courtroom stage, and the extra vocabulary of a criminal prosecution from indictment to sentence.

In a bench trial the judge decides the facts and the law. In a jury trial jurors decide the facts, and the judge decides the law.

More

Civil jury rights depend on the claim and a timely demand. Criminal defendants have a constitutional right to a jury for serious charges.

See alsoJury demandVoir dire

The questioning of prospective jurors to decide who will serve.

More

Each side can challenge jurors for cause, with no limit, and with a limited number of peremptory challenges that need no reason.

A document, usually filed jointly, that governs the trial: the claims left, witnesses, exhibits, stipulated facts and motions in limine.

More

It supersedes the pleadings, so a claim left out may be gone.

See alsoMotion in limine

The judge’s explanation of the law to the jury before deliberations. Also called the charge.

More

Parties file proposed instructions and argue over wording. Disagreement over an instruction is a common ground for appeal.

See alsoVerdict

The jury’s decision. In a criminal case, guilty or not guilty on each count, which must be unanimous. In a civil case, a finding of liability and damages.

More

Federal civil verdicts must be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise. New York civil juries may return a verdict with five-sixths of jurors, and California three-fourths. A special verdict asks the jury specific questions instead of an overall result.

See alsoHung jury and mistrialJudgment

A hung jury cannot reach the required agreement. A mistrial ends a trial without a verdict.

More

After a hung jury the case can be tried again. A mistrial can also come from misconduct or prejudice.

A motion asking the judge to rule for one side because no reasonable jury could find otherwise. Rule 50. Formerly called a directed verdict.

More

It can be made after the other side presents its evidence and renewed after the verdict. The criminal counterpart is the Rule 29 motion for acquittal.

See alsoRule 29 and Rule 33 motions

Post-trial motions in federal criminal cases. Rule 29 asks the judge to enter an acquittal because the evidence was insufficient. Rule 33 asks for a new trial in the interest of justice.

More

Both have short deadlines, generally 14 days after the verdict (for Rule 33, longer if based on new evidence). Judges rarely grant them. A decision can be appealed.

See alsoVerdict

Indictment

Federal

A formal charge issued by a grand jury, listing each count and the law allegedly violated.

More

An indictment is an accusation, not evidence. A prosecutor can file an information instead if the defendant waives the grand jury. A criminal complaint is a sworn statement of probable cause that comes earlier, often with an arrest.

See alsoGrand jurySuperseding indictment

A new indictment that replaces an earlier one, adding or dropping counts or defendants.

More

Prosecutors file them as an investigation grows or the strategy changes. Each version is numbered (S1, S2).

See alsoIndictment

Grand jury

Federal

A panel of citizens, meeting in secret, that decides whether there is probable cause to charge someone with a federal felony.

More

The defendant and the defense lawyer do not appear. Grand jury proceedings are secret (Rule 6(e)).

See alsoIndictment

A hearing at which the defendant is told the charges and enters a plea.

More

Most defendants plead not guilty at arraignment.

See alsoPlea

A defendant’s formal answer to the charges: guilty, not guilty, or no contest (nolo contendere).

More

A plea agreement is a deal with the prosecution, usually for a lighter charge or recommendation. The judge need not accept the recommended sentence. A guilty plea is entered in a hearing where the judge asks the defendant to describe what happened, called the allocution.

See alsoAllocution

Whether a defendant is held or released while the case is pending. Federal judges apply the Bail Reform Act (18 U.S.C. § 3142).

More

Release is the rule unless no conditions can reasonably assure the defendant’s appearance and the safety of others. Release can be on a bond, with conditions such as home confinement. A defendant ordered held is “remanded”.

A federal law requiring a trial within 70 days of an indictment or first appearance, with a long list of exclusions that stop the clock.

More

Judges commonly exclude time with a finding that the delay serves the ends of justice, so most cases run well past 70 days.

Brady material

Federal

Evidence favorable to the defendant that prosecutors must hand over, named for Brady v. Maryland (1963). Includes evidence affecting a witness’s credibility, from Giglio.

More

Related rules require prosecutors to turn over a witness’s earlier statements after the witness testifies (the Jencks Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3500).

See alsoDiscovery

A request that the other side give more detail on a charge or claim.

More

In a criminal case it asks the prosecutor to specify the charge. In New York civil cases it elaborates a pleading (CPLR 3041).

See alsoIndictment

Asks the court to bar evidence that was obtained illegally, such as through an unlawful search.

More

If granted, the prosecution cannot use the evidence. A hearing may be held.

Severance

Federal

A motion to try defendants or counts separately.

More

Granted when a joint trial would prejudice a defendant.

Latin for “guilty mind”: the mental state, such as knowledge or intent, that a crime requires.

More

Often the contested element when the acts themselves are not disputed.

A finding that the prosecution did not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. A person acquitted cannot be tried again by the same government for the same crime.

More

An acquittal does not decide a civil case on the same facts, because the burden of proof is lower there.

See alsoBurden of proof

A report by a probation officer on the defendant’s background, the offense and the sentencing guidelines, prepared before sentencing.

More

Both sides can object. The judge gets it, and it is usually not public.

See alsoSentencing guidelines

A federal system that computes a suggested sentence range from the offense and the defendant’s history. Advisory since 2005.

More

A judge must consider the range and the factors in 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a), and may impose a sentence above or below it, explaining why.

See alsoAcquitted conduct

Conduct a jury found the government failed to prove. A 2024 amendment to the guidelines (effective November 1, 2024) bars its use in setting the range.

More

How far a judge may still weigh the underlying facts under 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a) is contested.

See alsoSentencing guidelines

The defendant’s chance to speak to the judge before sentencing.

More

Also the term for the exchange at a guilty plea.

Restitution is money a defendant must pay victims. Forfeiture is property the government takes because it was used in or gained through a crime.

More

Both are part of the judgment of conviction, and both can be contested separately.

See alsoJudgment of conviction

The court’s written record of the verdict or plea and the sentence imposed.

More

The date it is entered starts the clock for appeal.

See alsoNotice of appeal

A period of court supervision after a prison term, with conditions. Breaking them can send the person back.

More

It is part of the sentence, imposed at sentencing.

The assignment of a sentenced person to a federal facility. The judge may recommend a facility, but the Bureau of Prisons decides.

More

A projected release date depends on the sentence, credits for time served and good conduct.

See alsoGood conduct time

Credit that reduces a federal sentence for good behavior: up to 54 days for each year of the sentence imposed (18 U.S.C. § 3624(b)).

More

Other credits can apply, such as earned-time credits for completing programs. Time served before sentencing is credited separately.

A pardon forgives a federal offense. A commutation shortens a sentence without erasing the conviction.

More

Both come from the President and reach only federal offenses. Neither ends a state prosecution, and neither decides a civil lawsuit.

10

Appeals

What happens after a trial court rules, and why some appeals appear before a case is over.

The short filing that starts an appeal. Missing its deadline usually ends the right to appeal.

More

The usual deadline is 30 days after judgment is entered in a federal civil case, 14 days in a federal criminal case, 30 days after notice of entry in New York, 60 days in California and 30 days in Florida. Some deadlines run from different events.

See alsoFinal judgmentNotice of entry

In New York, a paper a party serves attaching the signed order or judgment and stating it has been entered. The 30-day appeal clock generally starts on service.

More

A signed order alone does not start the clock, which explains why a notice of entry follows a ruling on many dockets.

See alsoNotice of appeal

A decision that ends the case in the trial court, leaving nothing to decide but enforcement.

More

Federal appeals are generally from final judgments (28 U.S.C. § 1291).

See alsoInterlocutory appeal

An appeal taken before the case is over, from an order that is not a final judgment.

More

Federal courts allow it rarely (28 U.S.C. § 1292). New York allows appeals from many orders on motions (CPLR 5701), which is why New York dockets show appeals while the trial court case continues.

See alsoFinal judgmentAppellate Division

The appellant is the party who appeals. The appellee, called the respondent in New York and California, is the other side.

More

Roles are decided by who appeals, not who sued. The name in the caption may flip.

See alsoPlaintiff

The written argument in an appeal: the appellant’s brief, the appellee’s response and the appellant’s reply.

More

An appeal is decided on the trial record and the briefs, and argument is not always held. Arguments not raised in the brief are usually lost.

See alsoOral argument

A hearing at which lawyers argue before the appellate panel and answer questions.

More

Judges often use the questions to test points in the briefs. Argument is not guaranteed.

See alsoAppellate brief

Affirm: the lower court was right. Reverse: it was wrong. Vacate: the ruling is wiped out. Remand: the case goes back to the lower court.

More

Common results are “affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded”. A remand has instructions that the lower court must follow.

See alsoMandate

How much deference an appeals court gives the trial court. De novo gives none and applies to questions of law. Abuse of discretion is deferential. Clear error governs facts found by a judge.

More

The standard often decides the outcome. A dismissal or summary judgment ruling is reviewed fresh.

The federal intermediate appeals court. The Second Circuit hears appeals from New York, Connecticut and Vermont.

More

Cases are heard by three judges. The Second Circuit issues precedential opinions and non-precedential summary orders.

See alsoEn bancSummary order

Summary order

Federal

The Second Circuit’s short, non-precedential decision, which resolves a case without establishing a rule other courts must follow.

More

It can be cited (Fed. R. App. P. 32.1) but does not bind later panels.

New York’s intermediate appellate court, in four departments. The First Department hears appeals from Manhattan and the Bronx.

More

It hears both appeals from final judgments and many from orders issued during a case. The highest court is the Court of Appeals.

See alsoSupreme Court (New York)Interlocutory appeal

The formal notice that sends an appeals court’s decision back to the trial court, making it effective.

More

Issues after the time for a rehearing request passes. Until then, the lower court cannot act on the appeal’s result.

See alsoAffirm, reverse, vacate and remand

Certiorari

Federal

The U.S. Supreme Court’s discretionary review. A party files a petition for a writ of certiorari, and the Court grants only a small number.

More

Four justices must vote to hear a case. A denial does not endorse the decision below.

An earlier decision that guides later ones (stare decisis). Binding precedent comes from a higher court in the same system. Persuasive precedent comes from elsewhere.

More

A trial judge in Manhattan follows the Second Circuit and the U.S. Supreme Court on federal law, but not decisions of trial judges next door.

11

Money, remedies & endings

How cases end and what a court can order a loser to do or pay.

Money a court orders a losing party to pay. Compensatory damages cover actual losses. Punitive damages punish especially bad conduct. Nominal damages are a token sum.

More

A request for damages in a complaint is only a request. Punitive damages are not available on every claim, and states limit them differently.

See alsoPrayer for relief

The court’s final decision resolving the claims, including any money owed.

More

A judgment is “entered” when the clerk enters it on the docket, and that date matters for appeals and enforcement. A proposed judgment is a draft submitted by a party.

See alsoFinal judgmentProposed order

A defendant’s failure to respond in time. The plaintiff can ask the clerk to enter default, and then ask the judge for a default judgment.

More

Courts prefer deciding cases on the merits, so a default can often be undone for good cause.

See alsoMotion to vacateAnswer

A plaintiff ending the case, by notice, by agreement or by court order. In federal court Rule 41(a) governs. New York calls it discontinuance (CPLR 3217).

More

Unless stated otherwise, a voluntary dismissal is without prejudice. A stipulation signed by all parties ends a case when a settlement is reached.

See alsoWith prejudice and without prejudiceSettlement

An agreement between the parties to end a dispute, usually with a payment and a release of claims.

More

Terms are often confidential and not on the docket. Dockets show the result: a notice of settlement, a stipulation of dismissal, or a conditional order that closes the case but allows it to reopen within a set time if the deal fails.

See alsoVoluntary dismissalMediation

A negotiation led by a neutral person who helps the parties reach a settlement but cannot impose one.

More

Courts often refer cases to mediation, and what is said is generally confidential.

See alsoArbitration

A private process in which a neutral arbitrator decides the dispute, usually binding and usually under a contract’s arbitration clause.

More

There is very limited appeal. Many contracts require it, which is why a defendant may move to compel arbitration.

See alsoMotion to compel arbitration

How a case or claim ended: dismissed, settled, judgment for one side, verdict, transferred.

More

A single case can have several: one defendant dismissed, another settled, a third tried.

Under the American rule each side pays its own lawyers, unless a statute or contract shifts fees to the loser.

More

A winning party usually must ask by motion and document the hours and rates. Courts can reduce what they find excessive.

See alsoAnti-SLAPP motion

Two lawyer liens. A retaining lien is the right to keep a client’s file until fees are paid. A charging lien is a claim on money the lawyer’s work recovers for the client (N.Y. Judiciary Law § 475).

More

Courts often let a lawyer withdraw but preserve the lien, and the amount can be set later. A lien can follow a case into a settlement.

See alsoMotion to withdraw as counsel

A signed statement in which a debtor agrees that a judgment may be entered against them for a stated sum, without a trial.

More

Used in loan and settlement agreements. New York limits it (CPLR 3218). It becomes a court matter when the creditor files it and asks the clerk to enter judgment.

See alsoJudgment

A filing that states a judgment has been paid in full.

More

Until it is filed, the judgment can appear unpaid in court files.

See alsoJudgment

12

Laws & deadlines

The statutes, rules and clocks that decide whether a claim can be brought at all.

The codes that say how a case must be run: the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Criminal Procedure, New York’s CPLR, California’s Code of Civil Procedure and Florida’s Rules of Civil Procedure.

More

The Federal Rules of Evidence cover what jurors may hear. Each court adds local rules and each judge individual practices, and the more specific rule wins.

See alsoIndividual practicesReading a legal citation

The deadline for filing a lawsuit, counted from when the claim arose. A claim filed late is “time-barred”.

More

Periods vary by claim and place. New York’s is one year for assault and battery (CPLR 215(3)), and the federal civil sex-trafficking claim allows ten years (18 U.S.C. § 1595(c)). It is an affirmative defense, so the defendant has to raise it.

See alsoTollingRevival windowAffirmative defense

Pausing the statute of limitations clock. Reasons include the plaintiff being a minor or the parties agreeing in writing.

More

A tolling agreement lets parties negotiate without a deadline passing.

A period set by a legislature in which claims normally barred by the statute of limitations may be filed.

More

New York’s Adult Survivors Act and New York City’s gender-motivated violence law each opened one. A claim filed inside the window is timely even if the old deadline passed, but the claim must still be proved.

See alsoAdult Survivors ActGender-motivated violence law

A New York law (CPLR 214-j) that opened a one-year window, from November 24, 2022 to November 24, 2023, for civil claims over sexual offenses against adults that were otherwise time-barred.

More

Many suits were filed in the final days. The law revived the right to sue, not any outcome.

See alsoRevival window

New York City’s Victims of Gender-Motivated Violence Protection Act (N.Y.C. Admin. Code § 10-1101 and following) lets victims sue over a crime of violence motivated by gender.

More

A 2022 amendment opened a two-year revival window, March 1, 2023 to March 1, 2025, for older claims. Abbreviated GMVA.

See alsoRevival window

A federal law against sex trafficking and forced labor (TVPA). It has criminal provisions (18 U.S.C. § 1591) and a civil claim for victims (§ 1595).

More

A civil claim can be brought against the trafficker and also against those who knowingly benefited. The civil statute of limitations is ten years.

See alsoStatute of limitations

RICO

Federal

The Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (18 U.S.C. §§ 1961–1968), which targets patterns of crime carried out through an organization.

More

A RICO claim requires an enterprise and a pattern of racketeering, meaning at least two listed offenses (“predicate acts”) within ten years. Civil RICO provides for triple damages and attorney’s fees (§ 1964(c)), so it is often pleaded and often challenged.

See alsoCause of action

Mann Act

Federal

A federal law criminalizing transporting a person across state lines for prostitution or other illegal sexual activity (18 U.S.C. § 2421 and following).

More

Passed in 1910. Prosecutions focus on the transporting, not on whether the sex acts happened.

Rules for counting days. In federal court (Rule 6) count every calendar day, skip the day of the event, and if the last day is a weekend or holiday the deadline moves to the next court day.

More

New York and California have similar rules (General Construction Law § 25-a; Code Civ. Proc. § 12). Deadlines set in a judge’s order are counted the same way unless it says otherwise.

Claim preclusion. A final judgment on the merits bars the same parties from suing again on the same claim.

More

It also bars claims that could have been raised in the first case.

See alsoCollateral estoppel

Issue preclusion. A fact or issue that was actually decided in one case can bind the parties in a later case.

More

A criminal conviction can bind a defendant in a later civil case on the same facts. An acquittal usually does not, because the civil burden of proof is lower.

See alsoRes judicataBurden of proof

13

Latin & legalese

Short phrases that turn up in captions, orders and briefs.

“Friend of the court”. A non-party that files a brief to offer information or a view on the case.

More

See alsoNon-party

“From one side”. A request or communication made without the other side present or notified, allowed only in limited circumstances.

More

Examples include emergency restraining orders and requests to seal.

“In chambers”. A judge reviews material privately, not in open court, often to decide a privilege or confidentiality claim.

More

See alsoPrivilege

“In the matter of”. Used in captions of proceedings with no opposing parties, such as estates and bankruptcies.

More

It also heads cases bundled together, such as “In re Smith Litigation”.

“Now for then”. An order given effect as of an earlier date, usually to correct a clerical error or an oversight.

“By the court”. An opinion issued by the court as a whole without naming an author.

“On its face”. Enough evidence to win unless rebutted. A prima facie case is the minimum a party must show.

More

A court deciding whether there is a prima facie case does not weigh the other side’s evidence.

“And others”. In a caption, signals that more parties are named than are written out.

More

See alsoCaption

All terms, A to Z

Entries are grouped by where they show up in a case. This index lists them alphabetically.